Shredded Email Review, pt. 5: How Many Posters?

Some of the angry people who are mailing me claim to be one of the transgender Shredded Moose-fans who went on a forum-posting spree in early 2014, but not the others. This runs counter to the general assumption that those posts were all made by one person. 

But then again, all the emails I receive may also be from just one person who pretends to be different people, a person who may – or may not – be the early 2014 poster. Who again may or may not be the guy(s) at Shitty Webcomics.

I was thinking (too much) about all this when it came to me: on the internet, if people say the same things, they are for all practical purposes the same person.

That sounds really weird, but hear me out:

There are no actual people on the internet, just the texts and images that people make. There is no “you” that exists independently from the stuff you post here. You are what you post. Everything else you may be, is irrelevant.

And if the stuff you post is so similar to the stuff that 10,000 other people are posting that your audience has trouble telling the 10,001 of you apart, then all of you are basically the same person on the internet.

Look at every internet debate ever: doesn’t the “discussion” tend to come off as just two binary opposite people screaming at each other? Like in Gamergate: it’s all a big shouting match between “The Gater” and “The SJW”.

If you butt into a debate with an opinion somewhere in the middle, your squeaky little voice will not be heard. Your opinion will only be noted if you join a mob and say the exact same thing as everyone else in that group, which again renders your participation in the “debate” completely fucking pointless.

In order to be part of something that has an impact, you have to give up your individual ideas and merge seamlessly into a pre-set pattern.

Wait, where was I going with this?

Yeah, that was it:
Hellspammers, don’t bother telling me you’re this person or that person, to me you’re just Generic Internet Whiner Type 1 or 2, nothing more.


Finally, here’s a contribution from someone decidedly unique: Mr. Garrison:

Well, that says it all, doesn't it.